Banana and Peanut Butter Nice-cream

In most home kitchens there’re the staple ingredients. The fail safes we can turn to for last minute adornments, or dish garnishes. For me the peanut is one of them. Round , shiny and golden as an acorn, it often makes its way into my recipes in some form or another.


Peanuts are a curious ingredient. It seems unfair that every bar in the country pays homage to them in their toasted salty form, whilst the more modest almond or walnut gets left to the wayside. That is unless you go in for a gastro-pub nut, which is a whole other level of smokey-chili fanciness.


As i recently found out, they are not technically a nut, but a legume. Perhaps one of the most versatile legumes at that. I can much see pureed lentils working their way onto my morning toast with as much glee.


The rich buttery texture it takes on in its most luxurious form, blitzed into peanut butter, slathered across hot toasted sourdough, with thickly sliced disks of banana and a lavish sprinkling of maldon might be one of my favourite instant, no-nonsense snacks.


Perhaps it is a food pairing that need little introduction. We all know about Elvis’s sandwich addition and no doubt Nigella’s peanut chocolate cake has lined our grateful stomach, at least once…oh lets be honest here, its at least thrice. I am astutely aware that, these recipes not have given it the best rep. It certainly isn’t so common to find a recipe that doesn’t require whipping out a pipe cleaner and  scrubbing the lining of your arteries at the mere mention of it.

I’m thinking this low-fat peanut-better, not butter, sweet heaven therefore might be a bit of a revelation. You can scoop it out of the tub, standing at the freezer door in you nightie, in full on Nigella (midnight raid) style and feel great about it. It doesn’t get much better…





Whether you opt for crunchy or smooth peanut butter is completely to choice, you can go either way. I tend to go for smooth, to achieve a really creamy texture. I also think that with the added crunch of the roasted peanuts there is enough texture already going on.

My favourite Peanut Butter is undoubtedly Meridian. Its natural, not overly salted and free from the dreaded palm oil that most nut butters, cereal, biscuits…. (you name it) are riddled with. It is definitely the one to use!

Their hazelnut butter is also a dream with chocolate and cherries… but you will have to wait for another post until that my foodie pals.


  • 3 ripe Bananas
  • 2 tbs Peanut Butter
  • 3 tbs runny Honey
  • 3 tbs 0% Greek Yoghurt
  • a pinch of Salt
  • 3 tbs roasted Peanuts


Mash the bananas with the back of a fork until they are a soft, slightly lumpy mush. Try to make them as smooth as possible.

Add the peanut butter, using the back of your fork to fully incorporate it into the banana mixture. Then add the yoghurt (greek is best) honey, a pinch of salt and 2/3rd of the roasted peanuts. Mix well.

Pour the mixture into a small tupperware container and freeze for 4 hours.

Enjoy with a few extra peanuts sprinkled on top.


This creamy nice-cream is a pretty good, caramel coloured, healthy-a-like to my uber indulgent, super easy No-churn Vanilla Ice Cream.





  1. This sounds utterly heavenly, I am getting the ingredients today to make it ASAP. Ben & Jerry’s Peanut Butter Me Up is my favourite flavour of ice cream, and I manage to find a way to put Meridian’s nut butters on pretty much everything I can. Are your peanuts roasted and not salted? We have a constant stash of KP roasted & salted peanuts in the larder but I fear that would make this healthy ice cream slightly more on the unhealthy side :/ Rosie x

  2. I made this yesterday and it was delicious! It even satisfied my Ben & Jerry’s loving husband. Thank you very much for the lovely recipe 🙂 Caroline x

  3. Hi Tess, tried this out but the mix has turned a really dark brown colour now that it’s frozen. Sort of like “overly ripe ready to be fed to the pigs” type colour. HELP! Why did his happen?

    1. Hey, it could be number of reasons. Possibly the bananas were VERY ripe and also if you used peanut butter with the husks.
      I use quite pale peanut butter with none of the outer skins, which likely affects the colour.
      Also if you didn’t freeze it immediately it would have had an affect as the bananas oxidise.
      Hope that helps.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.

You may use these HTML tags and attributes: <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <s> <strike> <strong>